By Kim Edward
Legal information checked: November 17, 2026.

A restitution order requires payment for qualifying financial loss connected to a criminal offence. It can be imposed alongside other sentencing measures, and it is different from a fine. A request for a particular amount is not itself a court order: the legal basis, supporting records and appropriate terms still matter.
If you are facing a theft or fraud case in Hamilton, restitution may become part of a sentencing discussion. You need to understand both the claimed loss and your own financial circumstances. An amount mentioned in disclosure, an offer to repay and a signed court order are different things.
This guide concerns adult criminal proceedings in Ontario. It explains what to prepare and clarify with a defence lawyer. It does not assume that a person charged with an offence is guilty, or that restitution will be ordered in every case.
When does the court consider restitution?
Under section 737.1 of the Criminal Code, a court must consider restitution when a person is convicted or receives a discharge under section 730. A discharge involves a finding of guilt without a conviction being registered. Being charged, by itself, is not the same as reaching this stage.
The Canadian Victims Bill of Rights, sections 16 and 17, gives victims the right to have the court consider restitution and, if an order goes unpaid, to have it entered as an enforceable civil judgment. The right to consideration does not mean that every requested amount must be awarded.
Before sentencing, the court asks whether reasonable steps have been taken to give victims an opportunity to seek restitution. The Code provides for information about readily ascertainable losses through Form 34.1, a provincially approved form or another method approved by the court. If restitution is requested and the court declines to order it, the court must give reasons.
For the defence, the practical point is to address the request before the sentencing hearing. Ask what amount is being sought, what documents support it and whether your lawyer needs further records. Do not wait until a figure is read aloud in court to raise an important discrepancy.
Restitution, a fine and voluntary repayment are different
Legal Aid Ontario explains that restitution is payment to the victim and is different from a fine or charitable donation. A fine is payable to the court. Paying one obligation should not be assumed to satisfy a different obligation in the sentence.
A restitution requirement may appear as a separate order or as a condition of another sentencing order, such as probation. The document containing the requirement matters. Ask for copies of all relevant orders and have counsel explain how they fit together, rather than relying on a remembered total or an informal description.
Voluntary repayment before sentencing is another distinct issue. Speak with your lawyer before arranging contact, returning property or transferring money. Any existing no-contact or other conditions must still be respected. Keep accurate records of lawful payments or returns so counsel can raise them through the proper process.
Repayment does not come with an automatic promise that a charge will be withdrawn or that a particular sentence will follow. If you are still at the early stages of a theft case, the firm’s guide to a first theft-under-$5,000 charge explains the broader criminal process. Restitution addresses a particular financial issue within that process.
How is the amount of property loss assessed?
Section 738(1)(a) deals with property damaged, lost or destroyed as a result of the offence or the offender’s arrest or attempted arrest. For that category, the amount cannot exceed the property’s replacement value when the order is imposed, less the value of any part returned as of the date it was returned. The amount must be readily ascertainable.
In plain language, the court needs an amount that can be established from the available information. A number written in a request is not a substitute for checking its basis. Receipts, estimates, transaction records and evidence of returned property may matter. The original purchase price, the amount alleged in a charge and the proper restitution figure should not simply be assumed to be identical.
The Code also permits restitution for other specified kinds of financial loss. This article concentrates on property loss relevant to theft and fraud cases. The same calculation should not be applied automatically to every type of claimed harm.
Hypothetical example: a request lists several missing items, but records show that one was returned before sentencing. Counsel needs to know what was returned, when it was returned and the information supporting its value. That does not determine the final order by itself, but it identifies a concrete point that should be checked before the amount is accepted.
If you disagree with an item, explain the reason to your lawyer and provide the underlying record. Separate a mathematical error from a disagreement about ownership, value or connection to the offence. A disputed amount is not automatically excluded, but a clear explanation is more useful than a general statement that the entire claim is unfair.
Does the court consider ability to pay?
Yes, financial circumstances matter, although inability to pay is not an automatic answer. Section 739.1 says that financial means or ability to pay does not prevent a court from making a restitution order. That should not be read as saying the court can ignore financial circumstances.
In R. v. Jeannotte, 2026 ONCA 79, paragraphs 24 to 26 and 43 to 52, the Court of Appeal for Ontario confirmed that ability to pay must be weighed and considered. The decision also addresses the effect of restitution on rehabilitation. It does not create a guarantee that an order will be refused whenever payment would be difficult.
Give your lawyer an accurate picture of your income, essential expenses, debts, dependants and realistic employment prospects. Identify anything that affects your capacity to work or meet a proposed schedule. Explain uncertainty honestly instead of presenting hoped-for income as money already available.
The aim is to help counsel make informed submissions. Do not conceal assets, invent expenses or promise a payment plan simply because it sounds helpful. A lawyer can assess the relevant information and discuss the proposed order with you, but no general article can predict the amount or terms a judge will choose.
What payment terms should you check?
Under section 739.2, the court specifies a payment date or, if appropriate, periodic instalments. Instalments are not guaranteed. The actual wording of the order controls, so an informal understanding should not be substituted for the written requirement.
Before leaving court, clarify the total, the person or organisation to be paid, the deadline or instalment dates, and how payment is to be made and recorded. If more than one person is owed money, make sure you understand the amount for each and any stated priority. Do not guess that a payment to one recipient counts toward another recipient’s amount.
Keep the order, payment instructions and receipts together. Record the date, amount and destination of each payment. If you receive conflicting instructions or cannot meet a payment requirement, seek advice promptly. Do not assume that a private conversation with a recipient changes the court’s order or authorises contact otherwise prohibited by your conditions.
What happens if restitution remains unpaid?
Section 741 allows a person owed restitution to enter an unpaid amount as a civil judgment when the payment date or an instalment is missed. The judgment can then be enforced through the civil court process. A stand-alone restitution order should therefore not be treated as a suggestion or an obligation that can simply be forgotten.
If payment is also a condition of probation or a conditional sentence, the consequences depend on that order and the circumstances. Do not assume that every missed payment has the same legal result. Bring the complete order and the reason for the difficulty to counsel promptly so the appropriate advice can be given.
There is also a current-law point about expiry. Section 740.1 continues an unpaid payment requirement in a probation or conditional-sentence order as a restitution order after that order terminates. The 2026 legislation, sections 115 and 205, limits this provision to orders concerning offences committed on or after July 18, 2026. A lawyer should check the offence date and the actual order before applying the rule.
The broader practical point is to establish what remains owing and which legal obligation applies. The end of supervision should not be assumed to erase an unpaid stand-alone restitution order. Equally, the new continuation provision should not be applied indiscriminately to older offences.
What should you prepare for your lawyer?
Organise the information into the claimed loss and your financial circumstances. This helps distinguish questions about the amount from questions about payment. The following is a practical preparation list, not a mandatory filing checklist for every case.
- The request and court documents: any restitution form, Crown position, proposed order, sentencing date and existing conditions.
- Loss records: relevant receipts, estimates, transaction statements and other documents explaining the amount sought.
- Returns and payments: proof of what was returned or paid, dates and any acknowledgements you already have.
- Specific questions: identify individual entries, duplicated amounts, calculations or dates you believe require clarification.
- Financial records: accurate information about income, essential expenses, debts, dependants and realistic future earnings.
- Practical concerns: difficulty understanding the order, accessing records or meeting a proposed payment schedule.
Preserve original documents and explain where each record came from. Do not alter records to make a position look stronger. Ask your lawyer how sensitive financial information should be shared; posting documents online or sending detailed case material through an unsecured enquiry form is unnecessary.
Family members can help gather existing records and organise appointments without negotiating directly with a complainant or making promises on the accused person’s behalf. Counsel should know if someone else proposes to help with payment, including whether that help is actually available.
Does restitution settle every possible claim?
No. Section 741.2 of the Criminal Code preserves civil remedies. A restitution order does not, by itself, settle every potential civil claim arising from the events. The significance of any separate agreement, payment or civil proceeding requires advice about its terms and the applicable law.
This guide addresses the criminal proceeding. Civil damages, judgment enforcement or insolvency questions may require separate advice from a lawyer practising in that area. Kim Edward Law’s confirmed role here is criminal defence, including the theft and fraud matters listed on its services page.
If restitution is being discussed in your Hamilton case, contact Kim Edward Law to ask about representation. Keep the initial enquiry brief. Before sending detailed financial records or case facts, confirm an appropriate arrangement for sharing them and obtaining advice.
About Kim Edward
Kim Edward is a criminal defence lawyer based in Hamilton, Ontario. Her practice represents people facing criminal charges.
General information only. This article provides general Ontario legal information, not legal advice. Reading it or contacting the firm does not itself create a lawyer-client relationship. Advice depends on the circumstances of your case. Read the website disclaimer.
Featured photo by Heather Green on Unsplash, used under the Unsplash License.