By Kim Edward
Legal information checked: October 15, 2026.

A character reference letter can help an Ontario sentencing court understand a person's background, conduct and available support. It should give truthful, specific information from someone who knows the person. It cannot promise a lighter sentence or replace legal advice about the case. Before asking for letters, speak with the defence lawyer about whether they would help and how they should be prepared.
For someone in Hamilton approaching sentencing, family and friends often want a practical way to help. A useful reference explains what the writer actually knows, rather than repeating praise or making a request the writer cannot support. This guide concerns references for adult criminal sentencing. Letters for bail, a trial, employment or professional licensing can raise different questions.
What can a character reference contribute?
Sentencing is the stage at which the court decides the appropriate legal consequence after guilt has been established. A reference can provide relevant personal information that is not apparent from the offence itself, such as a working relationship, responsibilities or concrete support available in the community.
Legal Aid Ontario's preparation guidance includes character references among potentially useful materials and stresses that information provided must be accurate and truthful. That does not mean everyone needs the same number of letters or that a reference will determine the result.
Under section 723 of the Criminal Code, the prosecution and the person being sentenced have an opportunity to present relevant information. The court can also require further evidence. A letter therefore belongs within the sentencing process, where its relevance and reliability can be considered.
The court must still apply the law. Section 718.1 requires a sentence proportionate to the seriousness of the offence and the person's degree of responsibility. Supportive descriptions do not remove those considerations or establish that a particular sentencing option is available.
Confirm the purpose before anyone starts writing
Ask counsel what stage the case has reached, what information would be useful and when the lawyer needs it. A sentencing reference should not accidentally become an argument about unresolved charges or a substitute for a witness statement.
If guilt or important facts remain disputed, raise that with the lawyer before circulating a request. No one should be encouraged to plead guilty simply to make a reference letter easier to write. The decision about a plea requires advice about the evidence, the law and the consequences.
Give the proposed writer a clear, limited explanation of the request. They need to know that the letter is intended for a criminal sentencing process, not an ordinary job application. Ask counsel how the writer should accurately describe their understanding of the offence and the procedural position. Do not ask the writer to pretend to know facts they have not been told or have not observed.
Also ask about the court, intended recipient, format and deadline. These are matters to confirm for the actual proceeding. An online example cannot establish a filing deadline or a special Hamilton requirement.
Choose writers who can offer first-hand information
The Ontario Superior Court of Justice's sentencing guidance identifies references from family, friends, colleagues and employers as possible material. The important practical question is what each person can reliably explain.
A supervisor may know about work attendance and responsibilities. A relative may know about day-to-day caregiving. A volunteer coordinator may describe participation they personally supervised. These perspectives are different, and the letter should make its limits clear.
Start with the relationship: how the writer knows the person, how long they have known them and how often they have contact. Someone who worked with a person years ago should say so rather than imply current daily knowledge. A short, candid description helps the reader understand the basis for what follows.
Do not choose a writer solely for an impressive title. Do not pressure someone who is uncomfortable providing a reference, or ask several people to sign the same account. Discuss proposed writers with counsel, particularly if a person is involved in the case or subject to a contact restriction.
Use concrete observations instead of broad praise
The strongest drafting habit is simple: connect each statement to something the writer knows. Instead of listing qualities, describe the relevant conduct and the period over which it was observed. This is a preparation suggestion, not a legal formula for obtaining a particular sentence.
For example, a writer who wants to discuss reliability can explain the responsibilities they personally saw fulfilled. A writer describing support can say what assistance they are realistically able to provide. They should distinguish a current arrangement from an offer that has not yet been accepted or put in place.
Hypothetical example: A colleague has supervised someone's weekly shifts for two years. The colleague can describe that working relationship and their own observations. They cannot verify counselling attendance merely because they heard about it from someone else. If counselling is relevant, counsel can consider appropriate confirmation from the provider instead.
Dates and details should be checked before the letter is signed. If the writer is uncertain about a date, they should say it is approximate or verify it. Inventing precision makes the letter less reliable. The same applies to a claim that a program was completed when the person has only registered or attended an initial meeting.
Discuss positive steps without promising future conduct
Rehabilitation is one of the sentencing objectives in section 718 of the Criminal Code. A reference may help explain actual steps or support relevant to that objective. It should not guarantee that a person will never offend again or claim professional expertise the writer does not have.
Separate what has already happened from what is planned. If the writer has provided regular transport to appointments, they can describe that assistance. If they are offering future help, they should explain the offer and its practical limits. A promise of unlimited availability may be inaccurate where work, health or family responsibilities restrict it.
Claims about treatment, diagnosis or risk need particular care. A friend can describe their own observations, but should not present a clinical conclusion as though they were the treating professional. Ask counsel what supporting documents are appropriate and how sensitive information should be handled.
A letter can be supportive while remaining measured. The writer does not need to explain every difficulty in the person's life or argue that positive qualities cancel the harm of an offence. Relevant background and honest observations are more useful than an attempt to make the situation sound simple.
Avoid blaming others or arguing the case
A reference should not attack a complainant, minimize established harm or speculate about someone else's motives. If the writer has information about a disputed event, they should tell counsel privately so that its proper use can be assessed. Inserting it into a sentencing reference does not resolve an evidentiary dispute.
Avoid statements such as a person could never have committed an offence, particularly where the letter is intended for sentencing after guilt has been established. The writer may be expressing surprise, but the wording can conflict with the purpose of the document. Counsel can help clarify that purpose without asking anyone to adopt a false account.
Similarly, a writer should not invent remorse, apologies or reconciliation. If they describe a conversation they actually had, they should make its source clear and avoid claiming to know what another person thinks or feels.
Do not ask someone protected by an order to provide a letter through prohibited contact. Do not use a relative or friend to pass along a request where indirect contact is restricted. Explain the situation to counsel and continue complying with every applicable order.
Keep the writer's voice and check the final version
A simple structure can help: identify the writer and relationship, explain the purpose, describe relevant observations, set out any genuine support and conclude respectfully. Use plain language the writer understands. These are organizational suggestions, not a mandatory court form.
Ask the lawyer what identification and contact information is needed and whether a signature or particular format is required for the intended use. Do not add identity documents, medical records or another person's private details just because a template includes a space for attachments.
Editing for spelling or clarity should preserve the writer's meaning. The writer should read and approve the complete final version, including any revisions suggested by someone else. Nobody should sign words they cannot explain or statements they know are inaccurate.
If circumstances change after a letter is prepared, tell counsel promptly. For example, an offer of work or accommodation may no longer be available. Keep track of which version is current so that an outdated promise is not submitted accidentally.
Send the letter through the proper process
Provide the letter to defence counsel in time for review. Ask how it should be transferred securely, whether supporting material is needed and how the lawyer will handle service and filing. Do not send a private appeal directly to the judge or assume an email to a courthouse has been accepted as evidence.
The Ontario Court of Justice's serving and filing direction addresses criminal documents, including sentencing briefs. It distinguishes receipt of an email from acceptance of the documents for filing. Have counsel confirm the court, applicable directions and submission arrangements for the actual case. A writer should not copy a filing method from a different court or online discussion.
Do not assume that a filed reference will remain private. Ontario's court-record access policy explains that criminal court documents can be publicly accessible, subject to restrictions. Ask counsel who will receive the letter and raise concerns about sensitive information, protected identities or publication restrictions before submission.
Section 723 also permits the court, in appropriate circumstances, to require a person's attendance or further evidence. A writer should not be promised that signing a letter can never lead to a question about its contents. Ask counsel about any concern before agreeing to provide it.
A reference is one part of sentencing preparation
A personal reference is different from a court-ordered pre-sentence report. Under section 721 of the Criminal Code, a probation officer prepares that report when required by the court. Collecting letters does not replace a report the court has ordered.
Other documents may serve different purposes. An employment confirmation can establish a work arrangement; a program record can confirm attendance or completion. Counsel can assess which materials are relevant and how to present them without unnecessary duplication.
The firm's guide to absolute and conditional discharges in Ontario explains those particular outcomes. A reference does not establish eligibility for a discharge or any other result. Sentencing advice must address the actual offence, facts and circumstances.
Before the deadline, confirm these points with counsel:
- What useful information can each proposed writer provide?
- Does each letter accurately describe the relationship and source of knowledge?
- Has the writer approved the final wording and checked any dates or promises?
- Are separate documents needed to verify employment, treatment or program participation?
- Have privacy, contact restrictions and the proper submission process been addressed?
Kim Edward Law's criminal defence services include assault, theft, fraud, drug and other criminal matters in which sentencing questions may arise. Hamilton residents can contact Kim Edward Law about representation and identify an upcoming court date. Arrange an appropriate communication method before sending detailed case information or reference letters.
About Kim Edward
Kim Edward is a criminal defence lawyer based in Hamilton, Ontario. Her practice represents people facing criminal charges.
General information only. This article provides general Ontario legal information, not legal advice. Reading it or contacting the firm does not itself create a lawyer-client relationship. Advice depends on the circumstances of your case. Read the website disclaimer.
Featured photo by Walls.io on Unsplash, used under the Unsplash License.