By Kim Edward
Legal information checked: November 19, 2026.

White pen on a closed cream notebook against a yellow background.

Yes. An assault charge can still be laid when a person says they acted in self-defence. That claim does not automatically end an investigation or a prosecution. If the legal requirements for self-defence are met, however, the person is not guilty of the offence. Being charged and being convicted are different things.

For someone facing an assault allegation in Hamilton, the useful next step is to understand what the law asks and which evidence may answer those questions. Saying that the other person started the incident, or that you were frightened, does not by itself settle the issue.

This guide explains the Canadian criminal-law framework as it applies in Ontario. It focuses on adult assault allegations involving physical force or a threat of physical force. It does not assess anyone’s case or provide instructions for using force.

What are the three parts of self-defence?

Section 34 of the Criminal Code sets out three requirements. The Supreme Court of Canada explains their different roles in R. v. Khill, 2021 SCC 37, paragraphs 51 to 69. All three matter; a strong answer to one does not replace the others.

The self-defence test at a glance

Reasonable belief

An honestly held belief, on reasonable grounds, that force is being used or threatened against you or another person.

Protective purpose

The act was done to defend or protect yourself or another person from that force or threat.

Reasonable response

The act was reasonable in the circumstances, considered in context.

All three requirements must be met. This summary is not a prediction of an outcome.

What did you believe was happening?

The first question concerns an honestly held belief that force was being used or threatened against you or another person. That belief must also have reasonable grounds. The court considers both what you actually perceived and whether there was a reasonable basis for it.

Khill explains that a reasonable mistake can be relevant. The question is not answered simply by discovering, afterwards, that the danger was different from what someone believed. Equally, a genuine fear without reasonable grounds does not automatically satisfy this requirement. Tell your lawyer what you saw, heard and knew at the time, and distinguish that from information learned later.

Why did you act?

The act must have been done for a defensive or protective purpose. This can include protecting another person, not only yourself. Wanting to punish someone, get revenge or teach them a lesson is different from acting to protect a person from force or a threat of force.

Your lawyer needs an accurate account of your purpose and the circumstances, rather than a description rewritten around legal terminology. Words spoken during the incident, the sequence of events and what changed as the situation developed may be important to understanding that purpose.

Was the response reasonable in context?

The third question is an objective assessment informed by the circumstances. It is not enough that a person believed their response was reasonable. The court must assess the act itself in its context.

Khill explains that the court considers the relevant circumstances and statutory factors together. These can include the nature of the threat, the parties’ physical capabilities, weapons, relationship history, other available responses and proportionality. No single factor necessarily decides the case. This is why a short account of only the final moment can leave out information that matters.

Do you have to be hit first?

Not necessarily. The law expressly includes a threat of force, so physical contact is not always required before self-defence can arise. That does not give a person unrestricted permission to act on a suspicion or a vague concern about something that might happen.

The Department of Justice’s explanation of section 34 distinguishes the required elements from factors used to assess reasonableness. How imminent the force was, and whether other responses were available, are relevant considerations. They should not be converted into a simple internet rule that always determines the outcome.

The same caution applies to the statement that someone else started it. In Khill, particularly paragraphs 74 and 75, the Supreme Court explains that a person’s role in the incident includes relevant conduct throughout the events. The analysis is broader than identifying who made the first physical contact.

For preparation purposes, give your lawyer the whole sequence. Include what happened before the confrontation, what each person did as it unfolded and when the perceived danger changed. Do not leave out an uncomfortable detail because you think it cannot help. Counsel needs to assess the actual facts.

Why might the prosecution continue?

A self-defence claim may depend on facts that are disputed or incomplete. Witness accounts, recordings and other evidence can present different pictures of what happened. A person making a claim is not the same as a court accepting that claim after applying the law.

Ontario’s Charge Screening directive requires a reasonable prospect of conviction and a public interest in proceeding. The Crown’s assessment includes likely defences and is ongoing as information becomes available. If the screening requirements are not met, the directive requires withdrawal. That assessment is separate from a court’s trial decision.

A defence lawyer can review the evidence, identify missing information and consider whether and how relevant material should be presented. There is no guarantee that raising self-defence will produce a withdrawal, or that every disagreement must result in a trial. The next step depends on the file and the stage of proceedings.

Who has to prove self-defence at trial?

A defence must have a sufficient foundation in the evidence before the court decides it. Lawyers call this the air of reality threshold. R. v. Cinous, 2002 SCC 29, paragraphs 49 to 54, explains this threshold and the distinction between putting a defence in issue and proving it.

Once self-defence is properly in issue, the accused does not have to prove it on a balance of probabilities. As the Supreme Court records in Khill, paragraph 18, the Crown must establish beyond a reasonable doubt that at least one of the three requirements is absent.

This does not mean that simply using the words self-defence is enough. Nor does it mean the accused must automatically testify. The evidence can come from different sources, and advice about presenting a defence or testifying requires careful assessment with counsel. A general article cannot decide those questions for you.

What information should you preserve?

Prepare an accurate account for your lawyer and identify existing records that may help test it. Start with the sequence rather than the conclusion. If you are unsure of a time, distance or exact wording, say so. Separate what you remember directly from what someone later told you.

The following checklist is for organising a discussion with counsel. It is not a direction to contact witnesses or collect material in breach of anyone’s rights or a court order.

  • The sequence: what led up to the incident, what you perceived, what you did and how the incident ended.
  • Existing recordings: video, photographs or audio already lawfully available to you, with their original files and dates.
  • Messages: relevant communications before or after the event, preserved with their context rather than selected fragments.
  • Possible witnesses: names and information you already have about who may have seen or heard something.
  • Injuries and other records: photographs and relevant medical or other documents already in your possession; tell counsel what additional records may exist.
  • Court paperwork: the charge documents, release conditions, next appearance information and anything received from the prosecution.

Keep originals intact. Do not delete messages, alter timestamps, edit a recording to remove awkward parts or ask anyone to coordinate accounts. If a recording is held by someone else, tell your lawyer where it may be found and why timing could matter. Counsel can advise on lawful preservation and access without you taking matters into your own hands.

Disclosure is the prosecution material provided to the defence. Reviewing it can reveal what a witness actually said, what a recording shows and what remains missing. Our guide to criminal disclosure in Ontario explains that separate process. Do not assume a brief allegation summary contains the complete evidence.

Family members can help organise paperwork and appointments. They should not become messengers to the complainant or witnesses, negotiate a shared account or circulate case material online. Ask the lawyer how sensitive documents should be provided securely.

What should you do about police contact and conditions?

Do not assume that explaining your position in an immediate interview is the only way to raise a defence. Get advice about police questioning and the circumstances of the investigation. Our separate guide to police questioning and the right to silence explains the distinction between speaking voluntarily and obligations that may arise in a particular situation.

If you have been released with conditions, continue to follow them. Believing that the charge is unjustified or that you acted defensively does not cancel those requirements. Bring any uncertainty about contact, attendance or another term to counsel promptly. Keep court dates and other required appointments while the case is pending.

This guide is about defence of a person. Protecting property raises separate legal questions, and section 34 has an additional limit where force is used in lawful administration or enforcement of the law. Do not apply a general explanation of self-defence as permission to resist police or disregard an order.

What should you ask a defence lawyer?

A useful consultation focuses on the legal questions and the evidence needed to assess them. Ask which part of the self-defence test is disputed, whether disclosure is complete, what records may need to be preserved and what must happen before the next court date.

Also explain any difference between your recollection and what appears in the paperwork. Your lawyer can help distinguish a factual dispute from a legal issue and discuss the available choices. Avoid relying on a promised outcome based only on a short account or a comparison with someone else’s case.

Kim Edward Law’s criminal defence services include assault and domestic assault matters. If you are facing an assault allegation in Hamilton, contact Kim Edward Law to ask about representation. Keep the initial enquiry brief and confirm an appropriate arrangement before sharing detailed case facts or sensitive records.


About Kim Edward

Kim Edward is a criminal defence lawyer based in Hamilton, Ontario. Her practice represents people facing criminal charges.

General information only. This article provides general Ontario legal information, not legal advice. Reading it or contacting the firm does not itself create a lawyer-client relationship. Advice depends on the circumstances of your case. Read the website disclaimer.

Featured photo by Sasun Bughdaryan on Unsplash, used under the Unsplash License.