By Kim Edward
Legal information checked: November 14, 2026.

A preliminary inquiry decides whether there is enough evidence to send an accused person to trial. A criminal trial decides whether the Crown has proved guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Being ordered to stand trial after a preliminary inquiry is not a finding of guilt.
For someone facing charges in Hamilton, those different purposes matter. Both proceedings can involve witnesses, lawyers and evidence, but they do not answer the same legal question. A preliminary inquiry is also different from a first appearance or a pre-trial meeting.
This guide explains the usual adult criminal process in Ontario. A preliminary inquiry is available only in certain cases, and not every prosecution follows the same sequence. Your charge, court documents and the directions in your own case determine what you need to prepare for.
Two hearings, different decisions
Preliminary inquiry
Question: Is there sufficient evidence to require a trial?
Decision: Committal for trial or discharge. The judge does not decide guilt.
Criminal trial
Question: Has the Crown proved guilt beyond a reasonable doubt?
Decision: A verdict on the charge. An earlier committal does not determine that verdict.
The comparison describes each hearing’s purpose, not a mandatory path for every case. Many criminal trials take place without a preliminary inquiry.
Who can have a preliminary inquiry in Ontario?
The current Criminal Code framework generally limits preliminary inquiries to indictable cases in which the accused faces an applicable maximum sentence of 14 years or more. Indictable proceedings are one of the ways criminal charges are prosecuted. The maximum is a legal limit, not a prediction of the sentence someone would receive if convicted.
Availability also depends on the mode of trial and the required request. In the ordinary adult process, the preliminary inquiry takes place in the Ontario Court of Justice before a possible trial in the Superior Court of Justice. Section 536 of the Code sets out the trial choices and inquiry request framework. It is optional and must be requested by the accused or the Crown where the legal requirements are met.
Older proceedings can raise additional questions about which eligibility rules apply. The Supreme Court of Canada’s decision in R. v. Archambault addresses the effect of the 2019 changes and the applicable maximum punishment. Do not determine eligibility from the offence’s current label or maximum sentence alone. A lawyer should check the alleged offence date, the charges and the procedural history.
If an inquiry is available, deciding whether to request it requires advice about the particular case. It should not be treated as an automatic extra step, a guaranteed way to end a prosecution or something to decline simply to obtain an earlier date.
What happens at the preliminary inquiry?
The Crown presents evidence to support sending the case to trial. Under section 540 of the Criminal Code, witnesses can give evidence and be cross-examined by the defence. Cross-examination means questioning a witness called by the other side. Its scope and purpose depend on the issues properly before the court.
The hearing does not necessarily reproduce everything that would happen at trial. The Code permits certain information to be received at an inquiry through procedures that differ from trial, with safeguards concerning notice and requests to question witnesses. Do not assume that every person named in disclosure must testify at both proceedings or that every document will be dealt with in the same way.
Preparation can include identifying the issues and witnesses for the inquiry. Section 536.3 provides for a statement identifying the issues on which evidence is sought and the witnesses the requesting side wants heard, within the time fixed by court rules or the justice. This helps explain why your lawyer may need clear instructions well before the hearing date.
The Ontario Court of Justice criminal rules also provide for a focus hearing when directed by the preliminary inquiry judge. That hearing can address how the inquiry will proceed, including witnesses and issues. It is a preparation step, not itself the decision on guilt.
Ask your lawyer what the scheduled appearance is intended to accomplish and what, if anything, you will be asked to do. Decisions about calling defence evidence or testifying should be discussed with counsel. This article cannot determine whether either step would be appropriate for you.
What does being committed to stand trial mean?
Under section 548 of the Criminal Code, the preliminary inquiry judge decides whether the evidence is sufficient to put the accused on trial. A committal is the order requiring the case to proceed to trial. It is not a conviction, a sentence or a prediction that the Crown will ultimately succeed.
The word can sound alarming outside its legal context. In this setting, being committed to stand trial describes a procedural decision about the prosecution. Ask your lawyer to explain the actual order rather than drawing conclusions from that word alone.
After committal, there is a further step in the trial court. The Code provides for a trial date or an appearance in the court where the accused is to be tried. Your lawyer should clarify which date has actually been set, what it is for and whether any other preparation is required before the trial begins.
Keep the written directions and next appearance details together. Do not assume that the next date is the trial itself, that the trial begins immediately, or that the inquiry has already settled every issue about the evidence.
What if the accused is discharged?
If the evidence is insufficient to put the accused on trial, section 548 provides for a discharge. That is a different result from committal, but it is also different from an acquittal after a trial. It does not mean the preliminary inquiry judge has conducted a full trial and returned a not-guilty verdict.
There are limits to treating a discharge as an absolute end to any possible prosecution. Section 577 of the Criminal Code permits a direct indictment in specified circumstances, including where there has been a discharge after a preliminary inquiry. A direct indictment is a special route by which a case can proceed to trial without the ordinary preliminary inquiry route.
Ask counsel what the result means for each charge and whether anything remains outstanding. If there are several charges or separate files, do not assume that a decision about one resolves all of them. Keep a copy of the order and obtain advice about the status of your own proceedings.
How is the criminal trial different?
At trial, the Crown must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The accused is presumed innocent. These protections remain important whether or not a preliminary inquiry took place. The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms protects the presumption of innocence and the right not to be compelled to testify in proceedings concerning the offence.
Depending on the legally available mode of trial, the case may be decided by a judge alone or by a judge and jury. In a jury trial, the judge deals with legal questions and instructs the jury on the law; the jury decides the verdict. A judge sitting without a jury decides both legal questions and the verdict.
The Crown ordinarily presents its case first. Witnesses may be questioned by the Crown and cross-examined by the defence. The defence may present evidence, but the accused does not have to testify. Whether to call evidence is a decision to discuss with a lawyer, not something to decide from a general description of court procedure.
The Superior Court’s criminal proceeding guide explains trial roles and stages. The Ontario Court of Justice trial guide also explains evidence, witnesses and the trial process. Evidence may be subject to objections and legal rulings. A preliminary inquiry does not turn the later trial into a formality or guarantee that the evidence will unfold identically.
A guilty verdict leads to sentencing. An acquittal is a not-guilty verdict. Neither outcome should be predicted solely from the result of a preliminary inquiry.
Is this the same as a Crown or judicial pre-trial?
No. A Crown pre-trial is a discussion with the prosecutor. A judicial pre-trial involves a judge and can address issues, preparation, scheduling and possible resolution. A preliminary inquiry is an evidentiary hearing directed to whether the case should go to trial.
The similar names can cause confusion when a family member hears that a case has a “pre-trial” or a “preliminary” date. Confirm the actual name and purpose of the appearance. A date for a discussion, a focus hearing, an inquiry and a trial should not be treated as interchangeable.
Kim Edward Law’s guide to Crown and judicial pre-trials explains those meetings separately. The distinction helps you understand which decisions may be made at your next appearance and what you need to discuss with counsel beforehand.
Preparing for the correct hearing in Hamilton
Start with the court’s directions for your case. Confirm the court, date, time, expected length and required attendance format. A previous remote appearance does not establish that an inquiry or trial can also be attended remotely.
The current Ontario Court of Justice mode of appearance direction requires participants at trials and preliminary inquiries to attend in person unless a judge orders otherwise. A Superior Court proceeding must be checked against that court’s applicable directions and the orders in the case. Do not apply one court’s attendance arrangements automatically to another.
Date selection and the hearing itself are separate. The OCJ’s scheduling practice direction describes a process involving a scheduling form and the Trial Coordinator’s office, followed by formal setting of the date in court. Your lawyer can confirm what has actually been scheduled. Confirm the arrangements in your case rather than assuming a particular local process or waiting time.
Before meeting your lawyer, organize the documents that identify the stage of the case:
- The charge documents and notices showing upcoming appearances.
- Any election, inquiry request, focus-hearing direction or scheduling document you have received.
- The disclosure provided so far and a list of anything you believe is missing.
- Questions about the issues to be addressed at this hearing.
- Any practical difficulty with attendance, interpretation or accessibility that needs to be raised in advance.
Provide records accurately and preserve originals. Ask how sensitive documents should be shared. Avoid contacting witnesses to coordinate accounts, asking anyone to change evidence or assuming a family member can handle your required appearance for you.
Keep hearing information private and clarify the next step
Attending court does not mean everything heard there can be posted online. Section 539 provides for restrictions on publishing preliminary inquiry evidence when an order is made. Other publication bans or identity protections may apply. Ask about the actual restrictions before sharing hearing details, screenshots or names.
After an appearance, confirm what was decided, which issues remain and the next required step. Family members can help with practical arrangements without treating an interim ruling as proof of guilt or a guarantee of the final outcome.
Kim Edward Law’s criminal defence services include preliminary hearings and trials. If you need advice about your case in Hamilton, contact the firm to ask about representation. Keep an initial enquiry brief and avoid sending confidential case details through the website form or ordinary email before an appropriate arrangement is confirmed.
About Kim Edward
Kim Edward is a criminal defence lawyer based in Hamilton, Ontario. Her practice represents people facing criminal charges.
General information only. This article provides general Ontario legal information, not legal advice. Reading it or contacting the firm does not itself create a lawyer-client relationship. Advice depends on the circumstances of your case. Read the website disclaimer.
Featured photo by Kelly Sikkema on Unsplash, used under the Unsplash License.